Theory and evidence from U.S. real disposable income and consumption.
DPIC96 × PCECC961960Q1–2026Q2Five research questions
Opening case Hendry's rainfall example motivates the difference between a convincing regression and a credible relationship.
An unexpected relationship
The model looked strong—then Hendry revealed the variable
Fig. 2 British prices and British rainfall provide the historical setting.
01
UK prices and a variable C showed a close nonlinear relationship.
02
A quadratic regression gave a good fit and significant coefficients.
03
With an AR(1) error model, the fit became “spectacular.”
04
C was cumulative rainfall in the United Kingdom.
This case warns about misleading econometric relationships. It is not automatic evidence of co-integration.
Why ordinary inference can fail
Persistence can turn accidental movement into false confidence
1 · REMEMBERS
Persistent levels
Earlier shocks remain inside later observations.
2 · ALIGNS
Apparent co-movement
Two unrelated paths can move together for many periods.
3 · INFLATES
Misleading tests
Conventional t-tests use the wrong reference behavior.
4 · MISSTATES
False economic story
A high R² becomes an explanation the data do not justify.
Fig. 3 The formula can be familiar while its time-series assumptions fail.
Controlled demonstration · synthetic data
Independent random walks still produce a significant OLS slope
Fig. 4 Independent innovations generate β̂ = 0.455, R² = 0.372, and conventional p < 0.001; the residual is not stationary.
Why stationarity matters
Three paths can rise, but they require different treatments
I(0): stable level
Mean and variance stay broadly stable. Shocks fade.
Trend-stationary
A predictable trend changes the mean. Remove the trend.
I(1): stochastic trend
Each shock shifts the future path. Difference once.
Fig. 5 A visible upward path alone does not identify the type of trend.
Random walk → first difference
Differencing removes the accumulated path
Xt = Xt−1 + utEach new shock stays in every later level.
→
ΔXt = utThe first difference contains only the new shock.
Fig. 6 If ΔXt is I(0), then Xt is I(1).
Differencing prevents a naive level regression, but it may remove a genuine long-run relation.
From spurious regression to co-integration
Co-integration asks whether the gap stays stable
Fig. 7 The levels drift, but their estimated long-run gap stays bounded.
ut = Yt − α − βXt
X and Y may each be I(1). They are co-integrated when this linear combination is I(0).
Boundary: statistical stability does not prove causation.
The diagnostic difference
The residual reveals whether co-movement is stable
Fig. 8 A spurious residual wanders; a co-integrating residual returns toward a stable mean.
Long-run equilibrium and short-run correction
Yesterday's gap creates today's adjustment
Last period
Y is 10 units above equilibrium.
+10
×
Adjustment speed
λ = −0.30
−0.30
=
This period
Correction contribution
−3
How to test the relationship
The tests form a sequence, not a checklist
1 · CLASSIFY
ADF
Is each series I(0) or I(1)?
H₀: unit root
2 · TEST GAP
Engle–Granger
Is one estimated residual stationary?
H₀: no co-integration
3 · TEST RANK
Johansen
How many long-run relations exist?
H₀: rank ≤ r
4 · MODEL
ECM / VECM
How does the system correct and forecast?
Estimate after rank choice
How to read the sequence
Each result determines whether the next step is valid
STEP
WHAT WE TEST
WHAT SUPPORT LOOKS LIKE
WHAT IT ALLOWS NEXT
1 · ADF
Each variable
Does the level contain a unit root?
Level: do not reject
First difference: reject
Treat as I(1)
Now test whether the variables share a stable combination.
2 · ENGLE–GRANGER
One residual
Does the estimated long-run gap return to a stable mean?
Reject no co-integration
The residual is stationary.
Evidence of a long-run relation
Confirm the system rank with Johansen.
3 · JOHANSEN
The whole system
How many independent stationary combinations exist?
Choose rank r
Trace and max-eigen tests support the same main rank.
Specify the VECM
The selected rank determines the number of error-correction terms.
4 · VECM
Adjustment and forecasts
How do variables respond after disequilibrium?
Significant adjustment
Diagnostics and out-of-sample errors are acceptable.
Interpret carefully
Describe correction and prediction—not automatic causality.
Decision guide A failed prerequisite changes the model: the sequence is a chain of decisions, not four unrelated tests.
Step 1 · Reading the ADF test
ADF checks the variables before we test their relationship
Level test
H₀: the series has a unit root
p > .05: do not reject the unit-root null.
The level may be non-stationary.
This is not proof that a unit root exists.
First-difference test
ΔXt = Xt − Xt−1
p < .05: reject the unit-root null for the change.
Non-stationary level + stationary first difference supports I(1).
Co-integration testing is appropriate when the variables have compatible integration orders.
Memory aid: ADF checks each variable. It does not, by itself, show that two variables share a long-run equilibrium.
Why VECM comes last
The model is valid only after two empirical gates are passed
GATE 1 · INTEGRATION
Are the variables I(1)?
ADF evidence should support non-stationary levels and stationary first differences.
→
GATE 2 · CO-INTEGRATION
Is the long-run gap stable?
Engle–Granger tests the residual; Johansen identifies the number of stable combinations.
→
MODEL · VECM
Short run + correction
The VECM combines recent changes with the previous equilibrium error. The selected rank fixes its long-run structure.
Model gate Without I(1) variables and co-integration evidence, an error-correction term has no justified long-run interpretation.
Step 2 · Engle–Granger in practice
Co-integration requires a stationary long-run residual
1 · ESTIMATE
Long-run equation
Ct = α + βYt + ut
OLS estimates the level relationship between consumption and income.
2 · EXTRACT
Equilibrium error
ût = Ct − α̂ − β̂Yt
The residual measures how far the variables are from the estimated long-run relation.
3 · TEST
Residual stationarity
H₀: no co-integration
Use residual-based critical values—not the ordinary ADF table.
Decision rule: a unit-root residual can drift indefinitely → no co-integration. A stationary residual is bounded and mean-reverting → evidence of co-integration.
Empirical design · FRED / U.S. BEA
Income and consumption share persistent long-run growth
Fig. 12 The two quarterly series rise together, but formal tests must decide whether their gap is stable.
266QUARTERS 1960Q1–2026Q2
258TRAINING THROUGH 2024Q2
8TEST QUARTERS 2024Q3–2026Q2
We use natural logs. Every unit-root test, lag choice, co-integration test, and model estimate uses the training sample only.
Empirical evidence · Step 1
Both variables behave like I(1) processes
Log income · level
p = .273
ADF with trend does not reject a unit root.
H₀: UNIT ROOT
Δ log income
p < .001
The first difference rejects a unit root.
RESULT: STATIONARY CHANGE
Log consumption · level
p = .800
ADF with trend does not reject a unit root.
H₀: UNIT ROOT
Δ log consumption
p < .001
The first difference rejects a unit root.
RESULT: STATIONARY CHANGE
Fig. 13 Non-stationary levels and stationary first differences support the I(1) classification required for standard co-integration tests.
Empirical evidence · Steps 2 and 3
Two main tests identify one long-run relation
Engle–Granger · intercept
p = .00036
Reject the null of no co-integration.
H₀: NO CO-INTEGRATION
Engle–Granger · trend
p = .00473
The conclusion survives a trend specification.
H₀: NO CO-INTEGRATION
Johansen trace
rank = 1
Reject rank zero; do not reject rank at most one.
VAR LAG 4 · BIC
Maximum eigenvalue
rank = 1
The second rank test reaches the same main conclusion.
5% CRITICAL VALUES
Fig. 14 Engle–Granger and the prespecified Johansen tests agree, although Johansen rank changes under some alternative specifications.
Empirical evidence · Error correction
Income carries the significant adjustment toward equilibrium
Fig. 15 The estimated equilibrium error is bounded around zero in the training sample.
Income adjustmentα = −0.1616 p < .001
Consumption adjustmentα = +0.0445 p = .081
Residual dynamicsWHITENESS p = .540 NO STRONG AUTOCORRELATION
Under this normalization, income responds significantly to the previous equilibrium error. Consumption adjustment is not significant at 5%.
Empirical evidence · Forecasting
Test whether equilibrium information improves forecasts
1 · ESTIMATEFit the rank-1 VECM on 258 training quarters.
2 · FORECASTUse short-run changes + the previous equilibrium error.
3 · BENCHMARKForecast the same 8 quarters with four competing models.
4 · EVALUATECompare RMSE and MAE; lower error means better accuracy.
Fig. 16 Fixed-origin forecasts use the same 2024Q3–2026Q2 test period for every model.
Income · VECMRMSE 225.8 · MAE 196.0 41.6% lower RMSE than drift
Consumption · VECMRMSE 114.3 · MAE 96.5 6.7% lower RMSE than drift
ResultVECM HAS THE LOWEST RMSE AND MAE FOR BOTH VARIABLES SHORT 8-QUARTER HOLDOUT LIMITS GENERALIZATION
Answers to the five research questions
A stable residual turns shared growth into useful information
Q1
Why spurious?
Persistent unrelated trends can create significant OLS results.
Q2
What is co-integration?
I(1) variables have a stationary long-run combination.
Q3
Why equilibrium?
The deviation stays bounded and enters the next period's adjustment.
Q4
How tested?
ADF classifies the series; Engle–Granger and Johansen test stability.
Q5
How forecast?
VECM combines short-run changes with the previous equilibrium error.
Conclusion The income–consumption evidence supports one long-run relation and useful VECM forecasts, but the eight-quarter test window limits generalization.
Time-series econometrics
Spurious regression or co-integration?
Shared movement is not enough. The residual must stay stable for the long-run relationship to be credible.
DPIC96 × PCECC96FRED data10–15 minutes
Fig. 1 Co-movement in levels does not prove a stable equilibrium.
The research route
Five questions move from illusion to forecasting
01
Spurious regression
Why can unrelated trends look significant?
02
Co-integration
When is a level relationship meaningful?
03
Equilibrium correction
How do short-run gaps close?
04
Statistical tests
What do ADF, Engle–Granger, and Johansen test?
05
Forecasting
Does the equilibrium improve predictions?
The logic is sequential: test persistence before trusting levels, then test equilibrium before using a VECM.
THEORY → TESTS → EVIDENCE → FORECASTS
Question 1 · Spurious regression
Persistence creates false confidence
Fig. 2 The regression formula looks ordinary; its sampling logic is not.
Yt = α + βXt + εt
01
Observations are strongly dependent across time.
02
OLS mistakes shared drift for repeated evidence.
03
The usual t-test no longer has its usual meaning.
A small p-value can describe a statistical artifact, not an economic relationship.